What is #ShameonShonda? Tweets from the Confusing Hashtag

I got back on Twitter today to find out that yet another hashtag has come up, but this one has me really confused, especially since I’m not a Grey’s Anatomy viewer. Apparently, there’s a hashtag called #ShameonShonda. Why are we on Shonda Rhimes’ case yet again?

Catherine Stone, founder of Postpartum Progress and advocate for proper treatment of  postpartum depression and other women’s health issues, launched a campaign on her Facebook page declaring a social media war against Rhimes and the latest storyline from Grey’s Anatomy, involving a mother who severely injured her kids as a result of a tumor. You can read the full story at SheKnows. Here’s her full statement about her initiative, as she wrote on Facebook:

Dear influential mamas (and dads for that matter)(and all women, for that matter, mama or not), I NEED YOUR VOICE TODAY. I need you to help me stand against stigma of maternal mental illness. PLEASE.

The main medical case in last night’s new episode of ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ involved a woman and her children who are being treated in the hospital. They were injured when the woman drove herself and her children off of a bridge.

Various characters then discuss this incident, including the following “banter”:

Callie Torres: G-d, is she one of those crazy moms that tries to drown her kids?

Meredith Grey: Maybe she needed a nanny.

Subsequently there are lots of “What kind of mother would…” comments by other female doctors.

As it turns out, the woman has a tumor that caused an insulin imbalance that effects cognitive function among other things, and it had nothing to do with perinatal mood and anxiety disorders, but the whole first half of the episode was unintelligent and uninformed bullshit.

PLEASE JOIN ME TODAY in letting Shonda Rhimes, producer of Grey’s Anatomy, know that we don’t accept this kind of stigmatizing of mothers with perinatal mood and anxiety disorders. Please tweet the following:

.@shondarhimes We stand against stigmatizing mothers with maternal mental illness. It’s NOT OK. ‪#‎standwithusShonda‬

OR, if you’re not on Twitter, please speak up on Facebook. We’re never going to be able to make a real impact on stigma if only the moms with PPD speak up. We need our fellow mothers to speak up with us. PLEASE SAY SOMETHING.

As I have said already, I don’t watch Grey’s Anatomy, so I have no frame of reference for where the controversy comes from. But apparently, some of the episode had some of the characters shaming the woman for what she did. Apparently, though, the other half of the episode combated the shaming. But anyway, the Twitter hashtag war began.

There are many people like me who just came on Twitter to find #ShameonShonda without any context. We are confused.

There are also people who are supporting  #ShameonShonda, saying that the storyline was problematic to those who have experienced extreme post-partum depression or other perinatal mental disorders.

However, the hashtag has been thoroughly silenced by  the hordes of people, black and white, taking over #ShameonShonda and exposing it for what it looks like (at least on the surface): a gang of white women on social media attacking Rhimes—a black showrunner—for having a touchy subject as a storyline. They also brought up the point that it’s ridiculous and against-message to have a hashtag shaming a woman even though hashtag is led by a woman who is against shaming women. One blogger, BattyMamzelle, took to her site to explain why this Twitter campaign has been viewed as a problematic one.

And also, there are those who are either confused or angry (or both) by this hashtag and unleash their emotions in humor.

One Twitter users, @AtlantaMom, tweeted this about the whole debacle:

I guess? I don’t know. As I’ve said all through this post, I haven’t seen the episode. But I do know that people have had a history about getting onto Rhimes simply because she’s on top, i.e. that tone-deaf New York Times article.

Of course, that’s not to say that Rhimes can’t be taken to task on some things; there are some storylines, like Olivia always running by a white (usually married) man in power, that not only don’t make sense, but could be seen as detrimental. But according to those who actually viewed the Grey’s Anatomy episode in question, there was a look at both sides of the equation when it came to the mother’s actions. And, if I’m being honest, didn’t Girls have an abortion episode? No one tripped off on that. And there’s that Homeland storyline I heard about concerning the main character nearly drowning a baby.  I didn’t see the same outrage over that, either.

So what I’m saying here is that I’m watching to see what happens with this. I have no stake in Grey’s Anatomy, but the mechanics of this Twitter hashtag kerfuffle are interesting in the larger schemes of feminism, particularly how “white feminism” is constantly at odds with “black feminism,” since this is really what this hashtag turned into.

What did you think about this hashtag battle? Give your opinions in the comments section below!

Photo credit: Ron Batzdorff/ABC

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “What is #ShameonShonda? Tweets from the Confusing Hashtag”

  1. WHYYYYY is everyfreakinthing turned into a race issue! !?
    This is about erasing the stigma surrounding mental health issues. Not about which race suffers more from them, or what race started a hashtag that was grossly misunderstood and twisted around.
    Mental health and the disparaging images that the media puts up, and how those play into the stereotype….period.
    ugh people piss me off.
    Stop worrying about what fucking color everyone is. And wake up. We can do more good in the world without everyone getting all divisive.

    Like

    1. “Stop worrying about what fucking color everyone is. And wake up. We can do more good in the world without everyone getting all divisive.” I see what sentiment you’re getting at. Unfortunately, it’s not that simple, for a myriad of reasons that would take too long to analyze in this comment. Thanks for your comment, though; it’s appreciated.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s